Your Rights Matter
Protecting Injured Clients Across Massachusetts

Studies examine the safety of an alternative birthing method

| Mar 29, 2014 | Birth Injuries

When a procedure goes wrong, getting a straight answer from a doctor or hospital can be difficult.

For example, many hospitals have their own counsel and carry liability insurance, as a precaution against medical malpractice lawsuits. To avoid admitting liability, a hospital may be uncooperative with a patient’s requests for information. Hospitals may also attempt to avoid a lawsuit offering a confidential settlement. An injured patient, unfamiliar with the court system, may be intimidated into accepting such an offer, even if it is not in his or her best interest.

An application of this institutional defensiveness is seen in the context of aquatic labor. Some obstetricians and doctors have questioned the safety of this practice. Yet evidence does suggest that water birthing is as safe as more traditional deliveries in hospitals, provided established guidelines are followed.

Specifically, a study involving 12 randomized controlled trials of 3,243 women found no resulting harm. An ongoing study of 1,200 women who birthed or labored in water also confirms that the practice is safe. There are differences in the procedure, however. In a water birth, the baby must be brought to the surface immediately, and the attending nurse must take the precaution of ensuring that the umbilical cord is long enough for lifting the baby.

If a birth injury did occur during labor or delivery, a patient may be unaware that medical negligence may have played a role in the incident. Regardless of the birthing method, it can be hard to investigate whether a birth injury could have been prevented. Fortunately, an attorney that specializes in medical malpractice litigation may have tactics for investigating and gathering evidence of what really happened.

Source: NPR, “Doctors Say Don’t Give Birth To Baby In A Tub, But Midwives Disagree,” Nancy Shute, March 23, 2014


FindLaw Network

Discuss Your Case With A Member Of Our Firm

Get A Free Consultation

health icon
The Advantage Of Having
Doctors And Nurses On Staff
We can review your case quickly and efficiently, without the delays you'd find at many other firms.
We have the medical knowledge necessary to understand — and prove — your condition.
We have strong connections with trusted experts in various fields of specialization.
We know how to gather the right types of medical evidence.
We know how to pick apart confusing medical records to make sense of everything that happened.